Saw is Great and Here’s Why: Top Ten Traps and a Loving Series Retrospective

Introduction

The first time I watched the Saw series I was far too young to be watching such things. My then best friend and I watched the films together, theorising with each other on how we would get out of each trap as easily as if we were speculating on an episode of Taskmaster. I then rewatched the entire run of the films with my cousin a few years back while we were both avoiding the responsibilities of our respective dissertations. I love these weird movies and I dream of writing my own one day. My love of Saw  should also come as no surprise to anyone who knows me even slightly  since I took my name from a protagonist in the first film. I give this background information because I want to highlight just how much I adore this franchise in order to put my criticisms into context. 

It goes without saying that there are gonna be some spoilers for the Saw movies in here so if you haven’t watched them go do that now and then come back to my article.

A Loving Series Retrospective

You don’t come to Saw for good films. The effects are brilliant, and the way the score and the camera work tricks you into rooting against the people in the trap is nothing short of genius, but you don’t put on a Saw movie expecting something the likes of Kubrick’s The Shining or Denis Villeneuve’s Dune trilogy. It would be like going to read a Creepypasta and expecting the author to have a perfect grasp of prose and narrative, that’s not what it’s about. And the same goes for Saw, it’s not about cinematic perfection, you come to see people getting ripped apart by machines and the excitement when the twist is revealed at the end of the film.

(That being said, I will be forgetting Jigsaw exists for the purpose of this think piece because it’s not only the worst Saw film, it’s also one of the worst films in existence.)

One more thing to consider before we get to the ranking is that for me to be able to rank the traps fairly—based on spectacle, intrigue, lasting memory, and complexity—we have to pretend that the logic of who gets put into a trap is justified. This is because a lot of the traps (a large portion of them not made by John Kramer himself) are very unfair and aside from Lawrence Gordon in the first Saw, William Easton in Saw VI, and the motel owner in the bedroom trap in Saw IV, there is no good reason for any of the victims to be tested. The victims’ choices that got them in a trap were mostly, if not all, born out of desperation forged by consistent poverty or moments of financial instability and distress.

For example in Saw II we have Addison Corday, she was put in the nerve gas house because she was (unjustly) arrested for sex work. I’ve had to do sex work, I know other people who have had to do sex work, and it’s nothing to be ashamed of.

Addison Corday in the razor box trap in Saw II

But we’re not here to talk about sex worker’s rights or the cinematic quality of the films, we’re here to talk traps.

So let’s get into the top ten.

The Top 10

10. The Mausoleum – Saw IV

This trap is very creative, but I can’t put it any higher in this ranking because we don’t even know why one of them is in the trap in the first place. The man with his mouth sewn shut is John Kramer’s lawyer, Art Blank, who stopped a lot of heinous people going to prison, but we have no idea who the other man is or why he’s being tested. It then seemed unfair for Art to then be forced into running Rigg’s game with the spine severing device on his back, he passed his test, let him live.

9. The Scalping Seat – Saw IV

This is a trap that has stuck in my mind ever since I first saw it thirteen years ago. The concept of it is utterly horrifying, having to rely on someone else to stop you getting your whole scalp ripped off is an awful concept to me. I suppose that’s why it stuck with me for so long. However, she was just a prop in Rigg’s game which seems like a waste of such a terrifying ordeal.

8. The Venus Fly Trap – Saw II

What an opener! The concept of having to dig around in your eye socket before you get skewered by a death mask resembling a venus fly trap is another horrible one that twists my stomach so well I can’t help but respect it.

7. The Classroom Trap – Saw III

I know this trap was completely unwinnable, even if he could rip the chain out of his literal jaw (he definitely couldn’t) the door was welded shut so he had no hope of escape, it was completely unfair but the visuals are awesome and the chains are so sick. I support Amanda Young’s wrongs.

6. The Glass Coffin – Saw V

My god the sexual tension in this room right now. I love Strahm’s realisation as the signature music starts playing and the viewer knows the classic Saw twist is coming, in this one even Strahm knows it. It was a masterwork of manipulating everyone in the FBI office on Hoffman’s part, and Strahm’s fate is so fucking BRUTAL! The only thing stopping me putting it higher on the list is the lack of artistry with the crushing walls.

5. The Reverse Bear Trap – Saw

I think now is the time to give the reverse bear trap its well deserved roses. The thing I love about this trap is that it’s 100% fair. Stay with me. The timer doesn’t start until Amanda stands up and triggers the rip cord at the back of her head, and to do that she has to fully stand up and step away from the chair which she can’t do while bound to the chair. There is no way to set off the timer while her hands are incapacitated. The reason I put such an iconic horror set piece at number 5 is because of how iconic it is, everyone knows the reverse bear trap, and it returns twice in future films. It’s a brilliant trap, and a great piece of iconography for the franchise, but there are more artistically crafted traps.

4. The Water Cube – Saw V

Strahm is quite possibly my favourite Saw character after Adam. This is another trap where the concept of it is absolutely terrifying. It stuck with me because it’s such a masterwork of fear (shoutout to the Buried—The Magnus Archives reference for those of you who still haven’t listened) and because of Strahm’s ingenuity in how he waits out the trap until someone can get him out.

3. The Angel Trap – Saw III

I know this was another unwinnable game, but the arms of the trap unfurling to look like a pair of wings is so artistically beautiful I can get past it being unfair. It’s not an overly complex trap either, there’s a beauty to it in its simplicity as well as the imagery.

Incredible painting by u/sp00kens_ on Reddit
Another incredible painting by soup_bag_ on Instagram

2. The Needle Pit

As someone with a crippling fear of needles, this is my worst nightmare, and therein lies its genius. The Magnus Archives episodes that stick with us are the ones that turn our stomachs and dig their claws into our deepest darkest nightmares, the same logic applies to Saw traps. Watching Amanda lay sobbing on the floor as she picks needles out of her body after being dropped in the pit that wasn’t even her trap, it fills me with such rage against Xavier that the trap sticks in my mind as a pinnacle of major injustice. This was Mandy’s game and she got fucked over by a big brute of a man, I’m glad she manipulated him into cutting off a piece of his neck and then watched him bleed to death.

1. The Bathroom

Lawrence absolutely deserves to be in this trap. He has a gorgeous wife and a sweet little kid and he’s running around having affairs? Jigsaw was right to shackle his stupid leg to a rusty pipe. The way the beginning of the trap shook out was an unfair stroke of cosmic fuckery, initially it was designed to be absolutely fair on Adam’s side, but then his key went down the drain. But my god the ending to that movie, the supposedly dead body standing up and shuffling over to the door to close it, locking Adam inside, with the final words of the movie being the classic ‘game over’ was a grasp of absolute mastery on James Wan and Leigh Whannel’s part. That first twist ending changed the landscape of cinema as we knew it in 2004, and while the rest of them have become the Saw franchise’s trademark, the first one will forever have a place in my heart along with Adam’s gut wrenching screams as his fate is realised.

Honourable Mentions

The Trial of Five – Saw V

William Easton’s Trial – Saw VI

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *