The Magnus Archives is a podcast distributed by Rusty Quill and licensed under a creative commons share-a-like 4.0 international licence.
If you have listened to TMA you’ve likely heard this phrase hundreds of times, and like me, probably recite it as a vocal stim incessantly to the point your friends want to hit you over the head with a metal pipe. I started listening to the show in 2022, well after it had ended. I spent the first few months of that year binge listening to episodes any chance I could get. Every walk to uni, video gaming session, or chore I had to complete I would listen to episode after episode until by April of that year I had listened to all 200. It quickly became one of my favourite ever pieces of media, my main special interest and the biggest source of inspiration for my writing.
And so I now see it as my duty to expose every horror fan who hasn’t listened to the show to its horrifying excellence. And so here I am to tell you about my top ten favourite episodes. It should be noted before we get started with this list that TMA, whilst predominantly having a monster of the week format, does feature an overarching meta-narrative surrounding uncovering why these supernatural things keep happening and why they keep happening to the archivist, Jonathan Sims (not to be confused with the writer of the show Jonathan Sims who also voices the character). If this is something you care about not getting spoilered for then I would recommend listening to the full show in order. But if you just want some 20-30 minute chunks of delightfully scary audio horror to sink your ears into, then I definitely recommend listening to one or all of the following episodes:
MAG 2 – Do Not Open
“Statement of Joshua Gillespie regarding his time in the possession of an apparently empty wooden casket.”
This story features one of the most competent protagonists of any TMA episode. Whilst a large appeal of horror is watching, reading or listening to the protagonist making terrible choices that lead to their horrific demise, there’s a certain satisfaction that comes from listening to Gillespie circumvent the horrors thrust into his life. This episode also introduces the recurring characters of Brekon and Hope, who you’ll want to file away for later if you plan on listening to the entire show. Overall, this is a good introduction to the tone and style of the show as a whole, and whilst you could definitely start listening with the first episode, Angler Fish, if you only care to listen to the episodes that I tell you to then I guess you could skip over the first episode. But you shouldn’t because Angler Fish is a classic.
MAG 15 – Lost John’s Cave
“Statement of Laura Popham, regarding her experience exploring the Three Counties System of caves with her sister Alena Sanderson.”
Episode 15 is where I really got hooked on the show. It really demonstrates the advantages of an audio only format for creating horror. I highly recommend listening to this episode in the dark or just close your eyes for the found audio section. I’d also say that if you’re someone who enjoys caving, this might illuminate your worst fears and cause you to no longer enjoy caving.
MAG 21 – Freefall
“Statement of Moira Kelly, regarding the disappearance of her son Robert.”
For this episode I want to say as little as I possibly can when talking about it so as to not spoil the incredible ending, so instead I’m going to take this opportunity to take a little detour and talk about my favourite of the 15 fears of The Magnus Archives, The Vast. Even before I knew of the phrase liminal spaces I’d been a fan. I loved wandering through the halls of my school with no one there, or exploring vast open fields round the back of my house that went on as far as the eye could see. Then I came to learn about concepts such as the backrooms or dreamcore and I finally had words to describe these feelings I’d loved for so long. And so if I were to be an avatar of any fear, it would most definitely be The Vast.
MAG 30 – The Killing Floor
“Statement of David Laylow, regarding his time working at an industrial abattoir near Dalston.”
My love for this particular episode comes from two things. The first being my love for fleshy horror and the idea of humans being nothing but animals a la Texas Chain Saw Massacre. The second comes from my memory of the first time I ever listened to this episode. As previously mentioned, I listened to all 200 episodes of the show over the span of a few months at the start of 2022. This meant that whenever I had headphones on I’d be listening to some poor protagonist getting trapped in an endless corridor or being chased down by monsters. And at this time I spent a lot of time on various trains going various places, but most commonly to Leeds. So, sometime in early 2022, late at night I was standing on the cold, crowded platform of Leeds train station waiting for my train back to York after some concert and the TMA episode I was listening to was The Killing Floor
I couldn’t help but think about all of the people around me funnelling onto trains, through barriers and down escalators. And how much like cattle they were. All being directed places by the machinery around them. Trapped in metal containers and penned in by fences. For the first time I truly registered that we are just meat. That we are made of the same stuff as the animals we slaughter for food. The only difference is that we pretend we’re not.
Then I’m pretty sure I went home and ate a burger.
MAG 33 – Boatswain’s Call
“Statement of Carlita Sloane, regarding her work on a container ship travelling from Porto do Itaqui to Southampton.”
All I can say about this episode is that I love the open ocean. I think that it’s an incredible horror setting, all that watery unknown, with the only thing protecting you from being lost in its depths being a rusting old ship that can barely withstand a light breeze, let alone a storm. Now imagine you’re alone on that boat with no land in sight. That’s what Boatswain’s call is about.
MAG 65 – Binary
“Statement of Tessa Winters, regarding a strange computer program she downloaded from the deep web three months ago. Statement recorded direct from subject.”
For any of you out there who were particularly excited by our last volume of What Might Kill You (Station 3, go read it here on the website or buy a copy) this episode will be perfect for you. We did recommend it as inspiration during the submission window, but for those of you who haven’t taken that hint by now that you should be listening to TMA here’s some extra encouragement. This is one of the few episodes of the show that genuinely freaked me out whilst listening to it. In an age of the digital takeover, the concept that this statement posits could very well be real. It’s like how when you watch an episode of Black Mirror now it hits a little too close to home to be Sci-fi anymore.
MAG 101 – Another Twist
“Statement of Michael, regarding himself.”
I’m a sucker for characters named Michael in this series, which you might say is just me being vain but there are at least three separate Michaels in this show. Michael the Distortion is most definitely my favourite of the bunch though. The nonsensical nature of the spiral very much plays into my love of all things liminal and backrooms. This episode gives you the backstory on Michael, and how he went from being just your average archival assistant to an unknowable thing that serves the spiral. If you want to listen to his introductory episode prior to this one, listen to Episode 26: A Distortion
MAG 103 – Cruelty Free
“Statement of Dylan Anderson, regarding an unusual pig he acquired on his farm in New Zealand.”
To talk in any way about this episode is to spoil it. Go listen to it…
MAG 130 – Meat
“Statement of Lucia Wright, regarding a hole filled with meat.”
The statement description says it all really. Hole filled with meat. People can’t stop throwing meat into the hole. Why are they doing this? Go listen to the episode and you’ll find out.
MAG 157 – Rotten Core
“Statement of Adelard Dekker, regarding a potential pandemic originating in the town of Klanxbüll, Germany.”
This episode plays with the concept of the emergence of a new 15th fear, The Extinction. A fear that was thought to have come into existence purely due to the species-wide destructive actions of the human race. The episode itself doesn’t really explore the concept in much depth since this is just one lead in a lifetime of searching for Dekker, who has dedicated his life to figuring out what The Extinction is and if it is in fact emerging. The real meat of the episode is about rot, decay, and infection. Themes that I absolutely adore and love to explore in my own work. If you want to listen to an episode actually about The Extinction then I would recommend episode 149: Concrete Jungle.
And that’s the list! I have plenty more thoughts and feelings about other episodes of TMA, the show as a whole, its sequel show, and everything else to do with this universe so don’t worry, this isn’t the last you’ve heard from me regarding The Magnus Archives. But for now, all I can say is happy listening, because you better have listened to at least one of these episodes by the time I next see you all.
Station 3’s Book Launch!
July was a very exciting month for Paw&Claw Ink, although we can’t actually share a…
Enter the Bog
Welcome to the Bog We here at Paw&Claw Ink are delighted to announce the launch…
Adam’s Top 10 Magnus Archives Episodes
My History With The Magnus Archives and why I love it so much Fear I…
